Are Cleansing Conditioners Worth The Cost?

RossBoss

Well-Known Member

LOL, I'm leaning towards this all being a bunch of marketing hype as @shortdub78 said upthread. A cleansing conditioner I believe is really just a conditioner with a smaller ratio of a gentle soap added, maybe castille soap. If this is true then the shampoo bars made by independent sellers on Etsy and other natural sellers would do the job of a cleansing conditioner at a fraction of the price.
 

RossBoss

Well-Known Member
@RossBoss
So, did you decide to go with Shampoo Bars?

Yep. I decided that any mild shampoo bar could pass as cleansing conditioner. Because I use such a heavy pomade during the day(Olde Jamaica JBCO pomade), I shampoo each night then coat my hair in EVOO, then rinse in the morning with a cheapie Suave conditioner. So far, so good.
 

RossBoss

Well-Known Member
@RossBoss
I bought that product once. :look:

That black stuff got all over my Pillowcases!:angry2: It seeped through my scarf/satin. cap:eek:

Are you getting good results from it?

Yes, I love it. I have not experienced it getting all over my pillowcase but then again I wash it out every night because it has beeswax in it and beeswax attracts dirt like you wouldn't believe. I only have 2 little strands of gray hair in my entire head so I am not an authority on gray hair (yet), but I can see this being benefical for people trying to hide the grays.
 

JJamiah

Well-Known Member
I still use Wen (Pomegranate), HairOne (olive oil or coconut oil), Shea Moisture Cleansing conditioner and Miss Jessie Cleansing conditioner. I honestly don't use shampoo but a few times a year when I get color.

I am currently getting back on the ball with taking care of my hair. I got real lazy.
 

IDareT'sHair

PJ Rehabilitation Center
@JJamiah
Currently using 613. I have a Liter of Fig and several Oils. And I have x1 Remoist I bought a coworker's TSV Liters, so I finally tried WEN.

Once I finish these up, they will not be a repurchase.

IMO: There are a lot of really "great" cleansers out there.
 

JJamiah

Well-Known Member
@JJamiah
Currently using 613. I have a Liter of Fig and several Oils. And I have x1 Remoist I bought a coworker's TSV Liters, so I finally tried WEN.

Once I finish these up, they will not be a repurchase.

IMO: There are a lot of really "great" cleansers out there.
I actually loved 613, fig caused me some hair loss, I only use the fig drops and will repurchase. I use the Pomegranate because I have a gluten allergy. I haven't found any cleansers that are worth leaving Wen :)
 

IDareT'sHair

PJ Rehabilitation Center
I actually loved 613, fig caused me some hair loss, I only use the fig drops and will repurchase. I use the Pomegranate because I have a gluten allergy. I haven't found any cleansers that are worth leaving Wen :)
@JJamiah
Loved the Pomegranate. Haven't tried the Fig (yet).

Been using the Oils for HOTs, I have quite a few of the Oils. I used the Tea Tree last Wash Day. Or Sweet Almond & Peppermint?
 

Rocky91

NYE side boob.
I tried the shea moisture one and the consistency of it just frustrated me. Mentally I wanted so bad for it do some foaming but then it still didn't have that thick/silky feel of my regular degular conditioners that I use to cowash. It's not for me. It did make a very nice shaving cream though, silky smooth legs.
 

Jade Feria

Well-Known Member
Back in my early LHCF days, co-washing simply meant washing with a regular conditioner.

If anyone remembers Creme of Nature's Detangling Conditioning Shampoo (green label - one of the best, most gentle shampoos I've ever used and I'm still mad they discontinued it), which contained cocomidaprobyl betaine, I would expect for most "cleansing conditioners" that have this ingredient to behave the same way.

Anything that doesn't have that ingredient, or
doesn't produce much foam or suds, I would use as a regular, actual cowash.
 

YvetteWithJoy

On break
Back in my early LHCF days, co-washing simply meant washing with a regular conditioner.

If anyone remembers Creme of Nature's Detangling Conditioning Shampoo (green label - one of the best, most gentle shampoos I've ever used and I'm still mad they discontinued it), which contained cocomidaprobyl betaine, I would expect for most "cleansing conditioners" that have this ingredient to behave the same way.

Anything that doesn't have that ingredient, or doesn't produce much foam or suds, I would use as a regular, actual cowash.

Yes!!! I remember that poo. Why, oh WHY was it discontinued?
 

Lucky me

Well-Known Member
Back in my early LHCF days, co-washing simply meant washing with a regular conditioner.

If anyone remembers Creme of Nature's Detangling Conditioning Shampoo (green label - one of the best, most gentle shampoos I've ever used and I'm still mad they discontinued it), which contained cocomidaprobyl betaine, I would expect for most "cleansing conditioners" that have this ingredient to behave the same way.

Anything that doesn't have that ingredient, or
doesn't produce much foam or suds, I would use as a regular, actual cowash.
Loved that shampoo. My hair was always clean . Then they revamped the whole line SMH
 

Cheleigh

Well-Known Member
I have been using a cleansing conditioner for a few years now-- DevaCurl No Poo. The consistency is different than the Deva Curl conditioner, so I wouldn't use the conditioner in lieu of the No Poo. I no longer cowash though.

I use a build-up buster every six weeks or so to minimize product build-up (although I don't use silicones, beewax, or other heavy products).
 

Honey Bee

Well-Known Member
Marketing ploy. For me personally I like shampoo. I love freshly was clean scalp and hair
Me too, but I'm thinking that maybe I could condense the first two steps of MHM if I make a 'cleansing conditioner' that contains both ACV and deep cond ingredients. :scratchchin: :bookworm:
 

Prettymetty

Natural/4b/medium-coarse
My cleansing conditioner doesn't rinse clean enough for me. It coats my hair, so I only use it every couple of months. I use Kerastase Curl Ideal Cleansing Conditioner. It's pricy, but it is very gentle on my hair and scalp.

Before that I would use Vo5 Kiwi lime clarifying conditioner with a few drops of castille soap. Cheapie, but it worked great!
 

ElevatedEnergy

Rooted Yet Flowing
I think cleansing conditioners are worth it depending on your wash cycle.

For example:
They are not worth it to me since I only wash every 2 weeks or so and by the time I get to it, I'd much rather just use shampoo to ensure a super clean slate.

However, I use a cleansing conditioner in my son's hair. I wash his hair on average every 3 days so I don't want to strip it every time by using shampoo. I love Curl Junkie Daily Fix. It removes enough dirt and sweat without leaving his hair dry. You only need a little to make it work too. I just replaced a bottle after using the last one for 2 years. Plus it doesn't burn should it get in his eyes. Win! I still wash his hair with shampoo but only after he gets a haircut (every 2-3 weeks) so a cleansing conditioner is not his only source of cleansing but it is his main source.
 

Alma Petra

Well-Known Member
I think it depends on how heavy the products you use on your hair are, and whether you leave them on long enough and reapply them multiple times before you decide to wash. If you don't get a lot of buildup then a shampoo might be too stripping for you and a cleansing conditioner should theoretically be better for your hair.
 
Top