Article: New Study Links Relaxers To Fibroids

nissi

Well-Known Member
Ya'll, I ain't trying to start no trouble, but my sister just posted this on her Facebook page. Especially in light of how many women I know deal/have dealt with fibroids, both permed and relaxed... mind you, it says "may be linked."

http://blacklikemoi.com/2012/02/bla..._campaign=Feed:+BlackLikeMoi+(Black+Like+Moi)

Source of the above article:
http://blackdoctor.org/news/article/Fibroids/New_Study_Links_Relaxers_To_Fibroids.aspx

Source of BlackDoctor article > Here's a link to search results on the American Journal of Epidemiology site with other alarming article titles. Unfortunately, you have to be a paid registrant to view the full article but you can access the abstract:

Abstract
http://aje.oxfordjournals.org/content/175/5/432.abstract?sid=aa958940-77af-47de-a91d-381b16267d28

Search Results:
http://aje.oxfordjournals.org/search?fulltext=hair+relaxers&submit=yes&x=0&y=0

Just wanted to share so that others could be duly informed, assess the risk and make an intelligent decision. Wow.

Here's the text of the BlackDoctor.org article in case you don't want to surf:

(BlackDoctor.org) -- A new study in the American Journal of Epidemiology has linked hair relaxers to uterine fibroids, as well as early puberty in young girls.

Scientists followed more than 23,000 pre-menopausal Black American women from 1997 to 2009 and found that the two- to three-times higher rate of fibroids among black women may be linked to chemical exposure through scalp lesions and burns resulting from relaxers.

Women who got their first menstrual period before the age of 10 were also more likely to have uterine fibroids, and early menstruation may result from hair products black girls are using, according to a separate study published in the Annals of Epidemiology last summer.

Three hundred African American, African Caribbean, Hispanic, and White women in New York City were studied. The women’s first menstrual period varied anywhere from age 8 to age 19, but African Americans, who were more likely to use straightening and relaxers hair oils, also reached menarche earlier than other racial/ethnic groups.

While so far, there is only an association rather than a cause and effect relationship between relaxers, fibroid tumors, and puberty, many experts have been quick to point out that the hair care industry isn’t regulated by the FDA, meaning that there's no definite way to fully know just how harmful standard Black hair care products really are.

Fibroid Facts

Fibroids are tumors that grow in the uterus. They are benign, which means they are not cancerous, and are made up of muscle fibers. Fibroids can be as small as a pea and can grow as large as a melon. It is estimated that 20-50% of women have, or will have, fibroids at some time in their lives. They are rare in women under the age of 20, most common in women in their 30s and 40s, and tend to shrink after the menopause.

According to US studies, fibroids occur up to nine times more often in black women than in white women, and tend to appear earlier. The reason for this is unclear. Also women who are overweight may be more likely to have fibroids. This is thought to be due to higher levels of estrogen in heavier women.

Although the exact cause of fibroids is unknown, they seem to be influenced by estrogen. This would explain why they appear during a woman's middle years (when estrogen levels are high) and stop growing after the menopause (when estrogen levels drop).

Most fibroids grow within the wall of the uterus. Health care providers put fibroids into three groups based on where they grow:

• Submucosal (pronounced sub-myou-co-sul) fibroids grow just underneath the uterine lining.

• Intramural (pronounced in-tra-myur-ul) fibroids grow in between the muscles of the uterus.

• Subserosal (pronounced sub-sir-oh-sul) fibroids grow on the outside of the uterus.

Some fibroids grow on stalks (also called peduncles, pronounced ped-uncles) that grow out from the surface of the uterus, or into the cavity of the uterus.
 
Last edited:

luckiestdestiny

Well-Known Member
Link pl and why trouble? This is new info and black women are plagued by fibroids, er I mean our community at larger rates. Someone might be interrested in knowing this.
 

Maayen

New Member
i am not surprised although empirical evidence and data would be great. Relaxers are full of lithium which interfere with the thyroid and liver so logically this could be true.

ETA: Totally useless study and talks nothing of control groups etc. Humans by definition are poor subjects for things like this as our systems are so complex, esp women. Also the study does not consider that women who do not relax are likely to be "natural" in all areas of their life and therefore more adverse to chemical toxins which may also go some way to explaining the incidence of fibroids in one group of women as opposed to another.

Basically making any assertions like this without any real empirical and statistically significant results is not really useful especially on a serious health issue that affects so many black women.

Finally I am natural but still feel that this article did more harm than good on the subject, felt a little like an attack as opposed to informed debate.
 
Last edited:

CheLala13

Well-Known Member
I didn't see this as a useless study, and definitely not an attack on black women. Considering that millions of women use hair relaxers, I found it a bit odd that there are very few studies done of the effects of them. I specifically remember researching journal articles to find information and almost all dealt with otolaryngology, when children would digest the chemicals. The purpose of this study is to show risk. When we see risk, other studies can be carried out to show direct cause. The American Journal of Epidemiology isn't some run-by-the-mill journal. I urge people to actually contact the researcher with questions, and I bet she'd find the time to respond.
 

DaiseeDay

New Member
I'm glad studies are being done.

People took the time to do studies and then made a big deal when they found formaldehyde in Brazilian blowouts, so I'd like the same effort given to us. Not that we have to or will listen to it, but it's nice to know.
 

beloved1bx

Well-Known Member
I almost didn't post this because I know the original post was closed since it seemed to be getting too messy. But I do know there are other ladies like me who wanted to read the original study. Someone over at the curlynikki forums copied and pasted the original article into a thread. Here's the link:
http://www.curlynikkiforums.com/non-hair-discussion/15437-fibroids-6.html
Scroll down to post #54

I found it interesting because there was no clear pattern of risk for those who were long term users of relaxers vs. those who hadn't been relaxing for very long. Nor was there one for those who relaxed 1-2 times a year vs. those who relaxed 7+ times a year, or the frequency of relaxer burns. I assumed that there would be a link for a woman (for example) who relaxed every 6 weeks and always burned, but that wasn't the case. The authors of the study explained why they think there is a link between the two, and then seem to state that a link between a relaxers and fibroids is merely a hypothesis, and further research needs to be done. They do not conclude that one causes the other.

Unfortunately black women are more likely to develop uterine fibroids, but they are also more likely to use relaxers. I haven't done a lot of research on this but I have heard that there is a stronger link that hormones (too much estrogen) have something to do with the development of uterine fibrosis.

Either way, the Fox news desk seemed to just take the title of the article and run with it. It doesn't seem to me like they actually read the study, so what they produced was over-sensationalized. Titling the news story as 'hair today, tumors tomorrow' is too much. They also mentioned that BU found relaxers causing early puberty which is actually a completely different study that isn't related (which i have not read). The validity/reliability of this fox news team regarding this piece is quite questionable to me.

It's great that the authors are researching a topic important to black women's health, and a good point was made that the FDA doesn't regulate relaxers, but the bottom line is that more researcher needs to be done.

(idk how this post got so long.)
 
Top