Hey ladies...I'm going to do my best to answer the questions asked:
TG- I'm not sure about the difference in potentcy; I've never tried the floral scent. But I remember a thread sometime ago saying that the floral may not contain the sulfur that the original does.
MW-I really want to say that Glovers is oil based...it's not at all thick, but it sure does feel oily if you rub your fingers together. I haven't had any sort of problems with reversion while I've used it...
Kaddy-I haven't tried the grease, so I don't know what to tell you about that one! Everyone I know who has gotten good results has used the liquid
PB-Nope, neither one of them smell remotely close to WG. S8 smells just like sulfur and vaseline (which I actually have grown to like). Glovers is a whole different story...it smells vaguely like liquid smoke...you know, what you put on the charcoal bricks in a grill? That's the best way I can describe it
HTH
Hugs,
Crys