If you don't put God in a box, then how is "God, three persons in one, Father, Son, & Holy Spirit" so impossible? It seems as though the only reason why this conversation is still going IS because everyone's putting God IN a box, and trying to make everything logically sensible. God is SUPERNATURAL! SUPERNATURAL doesn't make SENSE!
All I'm trying to say is that God's understanding is WAY WAY WAY beyond our understanding...that's what I mean when I say being logical is
not going to answer all questions. Some things can only be understood through prayer--and sometimes not even FULLY understood, but you'll atleast have a PEACE about it. I'll admit, I do not have a full understanding of the Trinity, but I know God is Sovereign, the Word says what it says, and that's the end of it.
Job 37:5
God's voice thunders in marvelous ways; he does great things
beyond our understanding.
Please understand, I'm not attacking you or anyone else that has questions/doubts/concerns about the Trinity. I'm only encouraging folks not analyze EVERYTHING. God's wisdom is so far beyond ours, that sometimes the only way to understand Him is through PRAYER-which is simply communication with Him. Your right, prayer is not the only way God speaks and reveals things, but it IS a way to discern things when everything in the natural is confused--including our silly little brains.